Welcome to Long John Silver's Elkhart
Long John Silver's Elkhart, located at 1724 Nappanee St, offers a nostalgic seafood dining experience that delights both locals and visitors. Known for its crispy, hand-battered Alaska pollock and all-white meat chicken, the restaurant features meals like the 3-piece Chicken Meal and the Fish & Shrimp Family Feast, perfect for sharing. Guests rave about the freshness and flavor, complemented by sides such as savory coleslaw and irresistible hushpuppies. The warm, friendly service—from the manager to the staff—enhances the inviting atmosphere, making it a cherished spot to create lasting memories, much like those shared by loyal patrons over the years.
- 1724 Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46516, United States1724 Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46516, United States Hotline: +1 574-293-2426
Welcome to Long John Silver's Elkhart, a cherished culinary gem nestled in the heart of Elkhart, Indiana. Located at 1724 Nappanee St, this establishment stands out not just as a fast-food joint, but as a nostalgic haven where many have created lasting memories. With the phone number +1 574-293-2426, you can easily reach out to them for inquiries or orders that perfectly capture that seaside experience without ever having to leave Indiana.
At Long John Silver's Elkhart, the menu is a delightful ode to seafood flavors and crispy comforts. Their 2 pc Fish Combo is a must-try, featuring hand-battered Alaska pollock that tempts your taste buds with each bite. If you're in the mood for poultry, the 2 pc Chicken Combo Delight offers juicy, lightly battered white meat chicken, served alongside two hushpuppies and a refreshing drink, capturing the essence of fast-food comfort.
Beyond these fan favorites, their Grilled Shrimp Meal brings a succulent seafood alternative, featuring perfectly grilled shrimp on a bed of rice. This meal allows customization with two individual-sized sides, ensuring a fulfilling dining experience. Speaking of sides, the hushpuppies have a rich history of being a delicious staple at fish fries, made even better with their crispy texture and mouthwatering flavor. And let's not forget the Cheese Bites—bite-sized nuggets of Wisconsin cheddar, expertly breaded and fried to golden perfection.
The atmosphere at Long John Silver's Elkhart is enriched by its friendly staff, as echoed in heartfelt customer reviews. Guests have spoken fondly of their experiences, recalling memories with loved ones and sharing hearty laughter with the warm-hearted team. Tiffany S Mechling reflects on the sentimentality tied to the place, evoking nostalgia from meals shared with her mother. Jennifer Oakley Busch emphasizes the warm service they received even close to closing time, highlighting how good food is not just about the dish but the experience around it.
Long John Silver's Elkhart is not just a meal stop; it’s a stop on the journey of flavors and memories. The consistently fresh food and welcoming environment make it a destination worth driving to, as many have noted. Jessica Peters and her family made the trip specifically for the food, proving the allure of the coastal cuisine served right here in this Indiana location.
So, whether you are in search of a quick bite or a nostalgic meal that binds family and friends, Long John Silver's Elkhart awaits to deliver that experience with each plate served. Indulge, enjoy, and remember the flavors that connect us all.

With this being one of the only Long John Silvers establishments left in indiana I always try to stop here anytime I'm in the area. This was one of my mom's favorite places to eat when she was alive and I have so many memories eating here with her throughout my life so it's very sentimental to me!

The manager herself served us.... 20 minutes before closing... fresh cooked delicious food for 5, a smile, a sense if humor, and a warm heart. We even had a great laugh about how awesome fish are.

We live out of town & our local Long John Silvers was closed down & myself & family have been craving it so we drove to Elkhart for Long John Silvers & it did not disappoint!! Food was fresh & delicious & the staff was very nice & friendly. Definitely worth the drive & definitely coming back! Thank you

Have not been to a Long Johns in years. Felt like stepping back. Great service, was only a couple individuals working so took a while for the food. But came out hot and delicious. Was a good choice, glad the whole family got to share in the evening.

I like their hush puppies and clams. The chicken is good too. Tasty. It's always clean, especially the soda fountain. That's so rare at most places.

The fish was amazing along with the hush puppies! My mother got green beans and coleslaw and she said she loved the way they seasoned the green beans. I got fish with extra hush puppies which I expected to be 2-3 extra but there was a lot more than I thought!! Me and my mother would definitely eat there again and HIGHLY recommend it to everyone!! It was a very good price for what we got.

LJS has been around for a long time. The food is always good and the prices are always reasonable. I really love the fact that they are expanding thier menu and including a lot more grilled menu items! Unfortunately the camera on my phone is bad which is why I don't post pictures. Maybe when I get a new one I will.

Fast service and good quality food. Love LJS. I secretly stop here and have lunch sometimes but just don't tell the wife because it's so bad for you! But man it is amazing. I do hope they never go out of business. I get the 3 piece chicken, fries and coleslaw. Yummy. I also love they serve Pepsi. So many have gone out of business and this one hasn't which I am so glad about. They are more and more rare to find which is very sad.